Just Build - Build vs Build vote suggestion

Just Build - Build vs Build vote suggestion

@GyrrabirdGamer and I didn’t find a Build vs Build vote suggestion. We know that there are many other suggestions that include “fair voting”, but Build vs Build voting is something completely different. I really hope it hasn’t been suggested before:sweat_smile:

Meh voters right now

Everybody knows it. You want to play Just Build, grind levels or do this fun “BUILD: Finish Top 3” quest. The “Meh voters” make it very hard for you because you hardly get any experience and have a very low score which is why you don’t win in the end c:
Screenshot_20210503-223207_Minecraft
No, my build wasn’t bad >:^(

Build vs Build vote suggestion

How would it work? :thinking:

The way the Build vs Build vote method works is actually quite simple. After the time for building has expired, 2 builds are shown side by side and you can vote for one of the two builds with the help of items in the hot bar (or use the report tool to report inappropriate, off-topic or racism builds)
This then evolves like a tournament. The round losers are out and the winners compete against other winners! In the third (and final) round 3 builds are shown next to each other so that the 2nd and 3rd place can be chosen better and it would not have worked otherwise. The image below shows this process again. You would not be able to vote for your own build (For example, if you are in team 6, you are not allowed to vote if team 6 and 7 compete against each other.) :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

The game of the image shown above

1st Round
Team 1 wins against Team 2 and moves on to the next round. Team 2 is out.
Team 3 wins against Team 4 and moves on to the next round. Team 4 is out.
Team 6 wins against Team 5 and moves on to the next round. Team 5 is out.
Team 7 wins against Team 8 and moves on to the next round. Team 8 is out.
Team 9 wins against Team 10 and moves on to the next round. Team 10 is out.
Team 12 wins against Team 11 and moves on to the next round. Team 11 is out.

2nd Round
Team 1 wins against Team 3 and moves on to the next round. Team 3 is out.
Team 6 wins against Team 7 and moves on to the next round. Team 7 is out.
Team 12 wins against Team 9 and moves on to the next round. Team 9 is out.

3rd (Final) Round
Team 1 wins against Team 6 and Team 12 and wins the game. :1st_place_medal: Team 6 and Team 12 are out. Team 6 and 12 are, depending on the number of votes, 2nd and 3rd place. :2nd_place_medal: :3rd_place_medal:

How would the teams that compete against each other be selected? :building_construction:

Very simple solution! The amount of blocks built makes it all. Let’s say the 12 players have the following amount of blocks placed:
145, 176, 235, 239, 491, 508, 76, 84, 278, 292, 343, 376

There are always 2 builds competing against each other that have roughly the same amount of blocks placed.

Here it would be:
76 blocks build vs 84 blocks build
145 blocks build vs 176 blocks build
235 blocks build vs 239 blocks build
278 blocks build vs 292 blocks build
343 blocks build vs 376 blocks build
491 blocks build vs 508 blocks build

In the end it will be decided which build was the best (although of course builds with many blocks and details have an advantage, but that’s kinda the game, isn’t it? c:)

What will happen if players don’t vote for a build? :bookmark:

Another problem that many are familiar with. Many players purposely don’t vote for builds or sometimes forget to do so.
If players do not vote in the “Build vs Build” method, both builds shown will get a point to avoid unfairness. In addition, the player who does not vote only harms theirself because other builds get more votes than his own c:

What would happen if both builds shown got the same number of votes (points) in a voting phase? (for example 5:5) :briefcase:

If both builds get the same number of votes, the build with the fewer blocks placed will win. This is my and @GyrrabirdGamer s decision. This is subject to change. Another possibility would be to give the player who placed more blocks the round win because they put more effort into it.

How would you gain XP?

→ Receiving a player rating - 0.5xp | Hive+ 0.75xp
→ Winning a round (against another build) - 5xp | Hive+ 7,5xp
→ Finishing in 1st place - 30XP | Hive+ 45xp
→ Finishing in 2nd place - 20XP | Hive+ 30xp
→ Finishing in 3rd place - 10XP | Hive+ 15xp

The pros and cons :arrow_up: :arrow_down:

Pros

→ 1. Fair game, because there are no more meh-voters and no more non-voters
→ 2. Balanced xp
→ 3. Ties can be avoided.
→ 4. A real “Build Battle” because it has a battle system.

Cons

→ 1. Changes the game (new system, you would have to become familiar with the new system first)
Uhh those were all downsides I think…

Thanks for reading! I look forward to your feedback and additions! :slightly_smiling_face:

11 Likes

This would be great so this way I dont get meh all the time so I can progress through my quest to get all max levels on all games

2 Likes

This is definitely much better than suggestions to punish meh voters, while still solving it. I don’t play jb, but this seems like this would solve some of its issues

3 Likes

As a contributor to this amazing suggestion, I absolutely love it. The concept of just build is a fun one, and I think this new system would definitely solve one of the game’s biggest problems.

3 Likes

This is an amazing suggestion! I can clearly tell alot of thought has gone into this! Would make the voting system much fairer and really spice up Just Build! :blobheart:

5 Likes

I usually don’t like big suggestions like these because they take a lot of effort to put in. The thing is, this suggestion would actually make justbuild a good game. You got my vote in :blush: there is one con that you didn’t add in though, it would make the game longer. I still think this is better than the current state of justbuild.

3 Likes

i wasn’t sure honestly looking at the title, but after reading the post i really love this idea! :slight_smile:

3 Likes

l hope this will be in The Hive :slight_smile:

I really hope they will add this soon. This is a great idea, and would definitely help a lot for Meh Voter. But one question, how would you decide you is second and third place?

In the final voting round, (between final 3) most votes is first, second most votes is second and least votes is third

1 Like