Segregate Players rather than Banning (Hacking Issue)

Idea: Segregate Players rather than Banning them

[banning stubborn hackers will just make another alt account. by segregating them from the legit players, these segregated players would less likely to create another minecraft account and more likely to play along]

the server will inform the player of their segregation and will offer them the same way as of getting them banned.

For example:
Instead of: You are banned from playing The Hive for 30 Days for Flying. You can appeal at … if you think that the ban is …
Do: You are segregated from other Hive players for 30 Days as a result for flying. Please do note that you are encouraged to hack during this period to compete with other hackers yourself. After the ban period you are expected to not use any hacked client or this may result in a permanent ban. You can appeal at … if you think that the ban is …

Also… The anticheat is active on the segregated players as well.

The benefits can be:
This can or will encourage the hacker to play the game with other hackers resulting for them hackers to realize how they look like and feel about their wrongdoings.
This can help in the improvement of the anticheat since the Hive Team can create on-the-spot testing and adjustment of their anticheat.
This can help the players

IP Banning is not a good idea. Some ISPs tend to use CGNATs (Carrier Grade Network Address Translators) that allows different customers to use the same IP Address

[This can be a viable solution and please make a constructive feedback below.]

i think this is a good idea. it would be a little complicated. if they are encouraged to hack, they might get used to it and do it after the segregation, then when they get banned, they’ll create an alt.

3 Likes

Just say separate instead of

It kinda has a bad connotation

1 Like

I’d rather not have valuable server space given to hackers. The point of banning them is to punish them for breaking the rules absurdly or repeatedly. Letting them have fun by playing with other hackers let’s them have fun playing on the Hive when they shouldn’t be. And if they don’t want to play in purgatory, they’ll create an alt anyways since it’s free.

2 Likes

If they are hacking they become a minority for 30 days, where hacking is acceptable, and the only way to win is to hack. This is a terrible idea and like why do we need to segregate players and not just ban them for their actions so they learn a lesson. Also this would require twice as many servers on all 4 regions, not something I think hive needs to run.

Wait so I have some questions, like what does this mean in combination with this?

Can they hack or not? Idk, I just think that they should be banned and that will be that

1 Like

yep for ab testing,

Which anticheat is better? Anticheat A vs Anticheat B.

Yes for anticheat improvement purposes.

AB Testing Experiment - For Anticheat Improvements

“A/B testing compares two versions of an app or webpage to identify the better performer. It’s a method that helps you make decisions based on real data rather than just guessing. It compares options to learn what customers prefer. You can test website/app layouts, email subject lines, product designs, CTA button text, colors, etc.” - wwo.com

They should lol. The anticheat is on but they will not get banned nor kicked. The anticheat will just adjust its settings for that specific player. It is for AB Testing purposes.

I just got destroyed too much by hackers in the asia region and I get ripped off too much that I don’t play anymore as often as much. This was a good question though. One day when they make another alt account to hack, the anticheat just learned from the cheating style of that player and the anti cheat should be more accurate as a result of such AB testing.

Anticheats work by detecting packets from hacked clients and some unexpected movements from the players.

Anyways, nobody seems to like to have a better anticheat for the hive. Or they just don’t like the idea of having AB testing to have the anticheat improved. They just want it to be improved using a miracle. This thread will be closed.

Cool but what does that have to do with my concerns?

Or, how about IP banning? If you haven’t heard of it, it’s where you take the IP of someone and ban it fully. That’s means that the person you’re banning won’t be able to use alts, either.

The only flaw is that the hackers can use VPNs like Nord to bypass it and still be able to play with alts. Although, if hackers want to waste their money just so they can hack, that’s not too bad.

Closed at the request of the original poster.