Hey there, ScythedPhantom here to clear some things up.
Cons
There are some instantly prevalent issues with this idea, and the main few are the issues of:
- Lower Playerbase
- High value of cosmetics now able to be bought with a fair bit of grinding
- Great setup now, why change so soon
My opinion on any other bought cosmetics being available through quest points extends ONLY to hats, and that is a stretch almost. As cool as it would be to be able to buy mounts and pets through extended grinding, I think if it should be available at all it should be through extended streaking, or certain max gamemode rewards (like a prestige in a game or something, idk).
Pros
With some of the cons out of the way, I’d like to talk about the pros, since I don’t want this post to be entirely negative, and it seems like you’ve thought about this idea a little, so I don’t want to completely bury your post with negative remarks. So with that being said, here are some pros to this idea:
- Potential boost to playerbase, if people already play Hive quite a bit, playing more and doing more grinding could be good incentive to maybe bring more players in
- This could be great if combined with the new “challenge master” coming in the Bedwars microhub
- Could be a cool opportunity for the Hive staff to add more quests to the questmaster, maybe create a more complete “Quest master 2.0”.
I don’t want to keep you here all day, so let’s finish up.
Statistics
Finally, let’s talk statistics. For the sake of the post, let’s say the price of a more high-value cosmetic is 2000QP. As a player with Hive+, you can get a total of 150QP per day, by doing both 30QP quests, all 4 20QP quests, and finally the 2 10QP ones you have left before you run out of quests, and have to wait for the daily limit to reset (reset happens at 8:00 PM EST). It would only take 13.3 days of that to get a cosmetic. That is way too fast and nobody would buy cosmetics anymore, just grind for a little while and you can get one for free, tanking the income of Hive. Even if the price was 8000QP, you’re still able to do that in roughly 2 months.
Last remarks
So to finish up, this could be a cool idea in theory, but I think it would require a complete overhaul of the Quest Master and how QP works, so in the end it won’t happen. I will still vote for this though, in case someone can find a good way to implement this into Hive. Thanks for posting, and I hope you can think of some good ideas in the future. Bye!